I’ve been watching most available Doctor Who episodes since “An Unearthly Child” and am on Season 18, the last with Fourth Doctor Tom Baker and Lalla Ward’s Romana. I just found out about these adverts for Prime Computer. They aired only in Australia and were written by Baker, presumably prior to the dissolution of his relationship with Lalla Ward. Interactive indeed.
Category Archives: Entertainment
UNIT and redshirts
It’s hard to tell who will have the shorter career — a UNIT soldier or a redshirt on Kirk’s Enterprise.
Me
North and South, Mrs. Hale on Milton (Manchester)
Mrs. Hale, the woman displaced by her husband’s conscientious concerns from the bucolic south of England to the industrial northern city of Milton (Manchester), has opinions about Milton and its residents. From the 2004 BBC series based on Elizabeth Gaskell’s North and South:
The people here don’t want learning. They don’t want books and culture. It’s all money and smoke. That’s what they eat and breathe.
Not just in 19th-century Milton.
Review: Miss Scarlet and the Duke
Moonlighting but with better settings, costumes, accents, and plots.
The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari: A tale of two actors
Werner Krauss (Caligari)
Krauss was an unapologetic anti-Semite who supported the Nazi party and its ideology. In 1933 Krauss joined the Vienna Burgtheater ensemble to perform in Campo di Maggio (German: Hundert Tage), a drama written by Giovacchino Forzano together with Benito Mussolini, where-after he was received by the Italian dictator and also made the acquaintance of German Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels.
Conrad Veidt (Cesare)
Veidt had long been known in German theatrical circles as a staunch anti-Nazi. His activities came under the scrutiny of the Gestapo, and a decision was made to assassinate him. Veidt found out about the plot, and managed to escape Germany before the Nazi death squad found him . . . When Britain went to war, he gave most of his estate to the war effort. He also donated a large portion of the salary from each of his movies to the British war relief, as well.
Source: IMDB
Previously, I was most familiar with Veidt as Jaffar in The Thief of Bagdad, a villainous role which he played delightfully. He made me a fan.
Hawaii Five-O (1968-1980)
In any conversation about memorable TV theme musics and openings, Hawaii Five-O has to make the cut. It starts with a drum set up, followed by dramatic racing brass backed by winds as a wave curls, then various images speed by — urban landscapes, Jack Lord on a high-rise balcony (lord of all he surveys), a car that somehow turns upside down, native Hawaiians (including a dancer who would go on to become a business professor), ocean, a glowering statue called “Lady Columbia,”1 jets and jet engine closeup (a reminder that Hawaii is an island chain), ocean sunsets, a dancer, nightfall (after which crime comes out, because now we’ll see the other members of Five-O, Danno, Kono, and Chin), and finally a flashing police light zooming down one of the city’s mean streets. (Any street can look mean in the dark with only incandescence, fluorescence, or neon to light the way.)
My parents may have watched the show in the early years, but if they did their viewing fell off because I don’t remember seeing it much. My dad preferred the Norman Lear sitcoms like All in the Family, The Jeffersons, and Maude, while my mother favored family-oriented fare like The Waltons and Little House on the Prairie.
I didn’t think of this when it was still current, but when it debuted Hawaii was a very young state, which must have made it even more exotic to the American audience. The state boasted an ethnic diversity unfamiliar to many Americans at the time. It’s also about as far west as the country could expand.
My dad had served in Hawaii before World War II and loved it (except for the pineapples — ”I never want to see another pineapple again.”). He hated Florida (hot and humid) but said he’d go to Hawaii in a heartbeat — a hesitant heartbeat. He knew what he loved about Hawaii was destined to be ruined by its desirability. The signs of overdevelopment were there before the war, which sped them along. When the camera zooms in on Jack Lord, he’s on the balcony of the Ilikai Hotel & Luxury Suites in Honolulu that opened in 1964 — only four years before the series began (1968–80). Someone who seemed to be familiar with Hawaii noted that at the time the Ilikai was the most prominent building on the island, but not anymore.
With the exception of a few storylines, Hawaii Five-O was filmed on location. That undoubtedly attracted some of the guest stars who appeared. As for me, I hated that nearly every TV show was set in southern California. Where were the forest and leaf colors and snows and classic houses of my native western New York (the Niagara Frontier)? Where were the wetlands of Georgia, the soft green hills of Virginia, the bays and inlets of Maine and Massachusetts, even the Petrified Forest of Arizona? Where was the America that wasn’t the streets of Los Angeles? Even shows that were supposed to be set in small-town America looked like southern California. Even alien landscapes on Star Trek looked like southern California. (When they were stuck in a planet’s glaciated past that couldn’t occur in southern California, it looked like a soundstage.) Hawaii Five-O may not have had snow, ice, big conifers, or any of the familiar hallmarks of the Northeast, Mid-Atlantic, or Midwest, but at least it didn’t look like Los Angeles. Mostly.
Like Los Angeles, Hawaii Five-O’s setting looks seedy and gritty, full of bars and replete with gambling, drugs, dancers, and many other temptations I don’t want to know about.
What I’ve learned about Steve McGarrett
McGarrett wouldn’t last long in his job today. He calls his secretaries, who spend a lot of time making and serving coffee, “love,” “honey,” and other inappropriate endearments. No one said boo in 1968, although one protests mildly about making coffee on Sunday. He also calls female witnesses “honey.”
In another throwback, Five-O officers and secretaries call McGarrett “Boss.” McGarrett calls Chin Ho Kelly “Fatso,” but only when he’s in a hospital bed or holding onto a gunshot wound. I’m sure that makes Chin Ho and his injuries feel better.
McGarrett has a bigger, better decorated office than many mainland CEOs. It’s on a par with the governor’s.
McGarrett takes off his mainland suit long enough each day to go for a morning run on the beach, which is convenient for the ex-serviceman who shoots him three times at close range and still can’t kill him.
In at least one two episodes, McGarrett’s car is parked perpendicular to the end of three slots. Scofflaw.
His peel-out parking style doesn’t keep him from being last at the crime scene.
You can feel Danno’s eyes roll when McGarrett declares, “No, it’s too neat. It fits too well. You could wrap it up, put a bow on it, and mail it in.” Or, “You’ll make a good cop one of these days, Danno.”
McGarrett is direct. When someone comes back to report, he usually barks out: “Go” or “What do you got?”
At the same time, he’s often skeptical about what they “got.” “I don’t buy it” or “It’s too neat.”
What I’ve learned about the “rest”
Danno is McGarrett’s no. 1, so he’s second in command of a team of four. No wonder he always looks anxious.
Chin Ho has family everywhere. Whenever McGarrett needs to know something, he sends Chin to ask a family member, or Kono says he heard news from a Chin Ho cousin.
Kono is street smart. We know that because he butchers English deliberately in a ways I have never heard before. (Think double negatives times 10 for starters.)
The governor of the 50th state likes to tell McGarrett, “I don’t have to tell you how bad [the crime du jour] is for tourism and business.” McGarrett visibly thinks, “It’s probably not so great for the victims, either, sir.”
Five-O
When McGarrett says, “Five-O” and whips out the badge, the tourists seem to know what he’s talking about. Did their travel agents brief them on the state police because they knew they were likely to witness one of Hawaii’s many, many crimes?
Five-O’s mainland suits and creeping dark sedans aren’t conspicuous in Hawaii at all.
Why Hawaii is appealing to tourists
I have no idea, because:
- To deal with killers and other criminals, McGarrett has the island(s) sealed off so many times that it’s a wonder they have tourists anymore.
- Hawaii attracts serial killers (which is odd since it’s hard for them to leave once McGarrett seals off the rock). In one episode, a hillbilly family arrives in Hawaii with 150 suspected murders behind them on the mainland. They dig right in to their avocation once on the island.
- Stabbings seem to be almost as popular as shootings, and both are more gory than in other police shows of the era.
- The real draw may be bubonic plague. It makes an appearance in two of the few episodes I’ve seen. (It’s also a reason for sealing off the islands. “Hawaiian vacation was lovely, Myrtle, but now we can’t leave because bubonic plague is going around.”)
Casting
Korean-American actor Soon-Tek Oh convincingly plays a nervously ruthless “red Chinese” agent, but I can’t say as much for Ricardo Montalban as a murderous Japanese deserter — who happens to have a crisp Castilian accent. That’s weird enough, but he’s being pursued by the “bushidō,” a secret society. Maybe the writer meant samurai, who adhere to bushidō, but since we’re talking secret, ninja sounds more likely. That’s what happened to TV writers who worked before Google. Whether samurai or ninja, they are remarkably ineffective at offing the Japanese gangster with the bad makeup job and Castilian accent.
6/11/2018 addition: Mark Lenard (Spock’s father on Star Trek) as a mentally ill Japanese ninja(!) who doesn’t know the war’s been over for 28 years and tries to blow up Pearl Harbor and half of Honolulu. Notably, McGarrett thinks a ninja is a warrior until he’s corrected by a karate master.
Ahead of its time
Hawaii has the Hawaii Institute of Technology. And, at a time when I’d heard of computers mainly in the context of science fiction, Hawaii has an “On-line Police Information System.”
Finally
Most poignant line: At the end of an episode in which a political appointee is murdered after turning pro-development, Kono looks out over a site being bulldozed for cheap boxy housing and says, “Look at that. One day we’ll be strangers in our own land.”
The strangest exchange I’ve heard so far occurs when Danno tells Steve he’s always one step ahead.
Steve: That’s why I got the big office.
Danno (turning around as he walks out): Peace and joy, strong brother.
1A symbol of motherhood on the far wall at the National Cemetery of the Pacific, also known as Punchbowl, she watches over the dead.
Emergency! (or what I’ve learned about firefighting in LA County)
When I was a teenager in the 1970s, I wasn’t fond of watching TV. On summer days and evenings, I was outdoors, riding my bike or hanging out with a friend. During the winter, I focused on school activities, homework, and reading (was I as boring as that sounds?). I watched Star Trek reruns, Buffalo Sabres games (although I listened mostly to the Ted Darling play-by-play on the radio), and oddball shows now and then. I loved How the West Was Won (the series with James Arness). Kung Fu fascinated me (don’t ask). I disliked most sitcoms, and shows like Baretta, T.J. Hooker, Starsky & Hutch, and CHIPS, and all their endless car chases. They were interchangeable and predictable and far too urban without being gritty.
I was working from home one day when I discovered Emergency! on COZI during lunch. I don’t know why I stuck with it, but I watch it when I can.
Emergency! was shot at an actual Los Angeles County fire station, so I’ve learned a lot about the area outside the city. Most of it makes me happy I don’t live there.
The fire station is nestled between an interstate (I-405, the San Diego Expressway) and a refinery (identified on a fan’s website as Atlantic Richfield). The immediate area is flat, cemented over, and depressing as can be. It looks like the inspiration for the memorable lines from “Big Yellow Taxi”: “They paved paradise and put up a parking lot.” If I were a firefighter, I’d want to be out on calls — except the calls may be to chemical plants and train derailments.
Here’s what I’ve learned since watching the efforts of Station 51, the Rampart General Hospital staff, and their supporting cast.
Station 51 and Los Angeles County
Fire station crews are tiny. We have our firefighter paramedics, Roy DeSoto and Johnny Gage, plus Mike (driver and actual Los Angeles County firefighter with a SAG card), Marco and Chet (sporting awesome 1970s-style mustaches), and Cap (Hank Stanley). KMG-365. Note: I discovered that in earlier episodes, Chet’s upper lip is buck naked. Chet without a mustache is like the 1970s without the Village People.
You can save a guy’s life over and over, and he can save yours over and over, but back at the station you can return effortlessly to being mortal enemies (Gage and Chet).
There’s one police officer for a goodly section of Los Angeles County — Vince. He wears a helmet, which made me think he’s a motorcycle cop — until I noticed he drives off in a cruiser. He has no partner. Isn’t that unusual?
Rampart General Hospital relies heavily on one pair of ambulance attendants. No wonder it takes them so long to arrive at the scene. They rarely show up before the squad. I don’t think they’ve ever spoken, but they do take orders from the firefighters.
Once I did see a different ambulance pair, but realized that they were responding to a night incident with the night shift paramedics and that this was one of the two-hour Emergency! movies.
Speaking of Vince-without-a-partner and the ambulance attendants (all two of them), Los Angeles County seems to have one speaking dispatcher. During his rare appearances, he’s usually seen from the side, occasionally with others in the background. Just as Mike Stoker was a working firefighter, he was a working dispatcher for the county (and uncredited on the show).
In the pilot, some of the ambulances appear to be your typical ambulance type, but one that carts an electrocution victim to the hospital looks like a hearse. This may be foreshadowing because without on-scene defibrillation, the victim dies soon after arrival. At least the hearses, er, ambulances shown in the early seasons are white or a cheery color like yellow. I’m glad that style was discontinued in later seasons.
Whenever Squad 51 leaves the station, there’s not much traffic. You’d think there’d be more traffic on a major four-lane street in an industrial area. They must not have gotten calls during shift changes.
If I didn’t know better, I’d think Gage can’t drive. DeSoto always drives the squad. (In real life the crew did a limited number of shots of the squad leaving the station, and Kevin Tighe happened to be driving — not unlike the Cartwrights, wealthy as they are, having only one set of working clothes so stock footage could be recycled many, many times.) In a rare exception, we see Gage move the squad at the scene to a spot closer to the victim, and later in the same episode he hops into the driver’s seat and takes off. I guess he can drive after all.
Given the freeway behind and the refinery in front, I don’t want to see what their lungs look like. That’s before taking into account work hazards like smoke inhalation and chemical exposure.
Speaking of chemicals, firefighters have to be well educated about them. They have to know how volatile, toxic, etc., they are, and how to neutralize them. Not only do they deal with house fires, but also factory and lab fires, plane and helicopter crashes, train derailments, and truck accidents. And, of course, explosions.
In Los Angeles County, simple rope is a must. Lots and lots of rope. You can’t have enough rope. Rope comes in handy because many accidents happen in canyons. As flat as the area around the station is, the county itself isn’t. People drive off roads into canyons, fall off motorcycles and bicycles into canyons, and otherwise find themselves in canyons.
If the canyons don’t claim you, the cliffs of the seashore will.
And if the seashore doesn’t get you, a high-rise or a high area in an industrial plant will.
In at least one episode, the station is called to an area where the houses are right off the road — no front yards and no room for error if a driver isn’t sharp. As we accompany our heroes, we learn that these houses are on stilts holding them up over a canyon behind them. Take up sleepwalking and plunge to your death — right from the comfort of your own home.
It’s critical for the Los Angeles County dispatcher to tell Station 51 whether to approach from the top or bottom (see “canyons”). We don’t have that issue in Cook County, Illinois.
When you lose something in the grass, look very carefully because you could startle a venomous snake like a rattler. Gage finds that out the hard way. In a canyon, of course.
Wildfires look terrifying. When you’re told to get out, you get out. They can spread and surround you fast — especially if you’re in a canyon. How do firefighters contain such large-scale conflagrations and put them out?
Los Angeles County has a lot of dirt roads.
I learn about rescue equipment I’ve never heard of. My favorites are the Porta Power, a super jack that helps our heroes lift cars and other weights off victims, or open doors, and the Stokes, a rigid basket that’s perfect for getting seriously injured people out of precarious situations (see “canyons”).
We also see how various hoses, nozzles, pressures, and so forth are used. This is a TV program that’s not afraid to use jargon, with viewers who are not afraid to hear it.
D5W and Ringer’s lactate treat almost everything. One or the other is prescribed by the ER doctors on most calls. When an IV is inserted, a paramedic has to ride along in the ambulance. (The ambulance attendees are mostly there for muscle to move the victims from the scene to the vehicle and from the vehicle to the ER treatment room.) That takes the paramedic out of circulation for the next call, which frustrates DeSoto and Gage, especially in one episode where some of the conditions don’t seem serious enough to warrant an IV.
Depending on your condition (bisecting aneurysm), you can have normal blood pressure in one arm and very high blood pressure in the other.
I’ve finally gotten my head wrapped around atrial fibrillation vs. ventricular fibrillation. (And I’ve had CPR training.) Unlike some other shows, Emergency! gets ventricular fibrillation right. Once you flatline, there’s no coming back.
Station 51 has a mascot, and he’s not a Dalmatian. No, he’s a basset hound named Henry. While Cap is studying to become a battalion chief, he finds Chet polishing equipment with Henry’s ears. He’s pretty sure that’s not by the book. Better Henry’s ears than Chet’s mustache, I say.
Rampart General Hospital
People in the 1970s were polite. They usually ask the Rampart doctor or nurse if it’s okay to smoke in the hospital. The answer is usually “yes.” Do not try this today.
Rampart nurses were still wearing the traditional nurse cap in addition to white dresses and clunky white shoes. (I went shoe shopping with a nurse once. The choices were clunky white, clunkier white, and chunkiest white.) The nurse cap had disappeared in the United States some time in the 1980s with the switch to scrubs.
I wonder why a county hospital in a highly populated area wouldn’t have more than one ER nurse? Yet Dixie often seems to be it. To be fair, others occasionally turn up in the treatment rooms, but more often than not DeSoto, Gage, or one of the ambulance guys is left to hold the IV bag.
Between car accidents, heart attacks, suicide attempts, poisonings, overdoses, fires, industrial mishaps, etc., the ER doctors and Dixie consume a lot of coffee. When they aren’t drinking coffee, DeSoto and Gage are stealing from the pot. Who makes the coffee and washes the cups with all those emergencies?
Emergency! miscellany
A lot of 1960s and 1970s TV shows featured actors wearing spectacularly bad wigs, and Emergency! is one of them. False hair abounds, and not only on men with little or no hair. It’s like all the time was devoted to makeup, and there wasn’t enough time to style hair properly.
In the pilot, a propeller severs a teenager’s arm. Our heroes, not yet paramedics because the paramedic program at that time is still one legislator’s dream, go to the scene, calculate the direction based on rotation, and find the missing arm, which remains out of our sight. You can only imagine how gruesome this work is without convenient camera angles and stage props to shield us.
In another incident, an epileptic boy climbs up a very high expressway pillar and can’t get down. Cap and the paramedics ask the Rampart doctors if the stress of being up there and being rescued could trigger a grand mal seizure. The doctors have to look it up. I’m screaming, “OF COURSE IT COULD!” I don’t even play a doctor on TV.
The people DeSoto and Gage rescue and the doctors save (or not) bleed very little and have the courtesy to suffer burns on covered parts of the body. Not that there aren’t hints of worse. A worker, his leg firmly trapped, has to choose between being crushed by a building wall or having his leg amputated so he can be freed in time. (Spoiler: He chooses amputation, but just as our heroes are swallowing their hesitation and getting ready to carve, his leg is freed. The wall topples almost immediately.)
On occasion, the paramedics are called on to rescue animals. Fortunately for them, in one episode the missing Grover turns up in a pen along with other dogs displaced by a wildfire. In another, it’s animal control officers who search for a baby goat among the flames and smoke and Dr. Brackett who’s bullied by his team into operating on it and its heart issues, guided over the phone by a congenial veterinarian.
One of the show’s most impressive conflagrations occurs when a worker flips a lit cigarette into a Dumpster during a propane transfer at a massive research complex (think lots of chemicals). Explosion after explosion. My first thought was, shouldn’t smoking materials of any kind be prohibited in such an environment? And why would a smoker choose to work day in and day out around propane?
I haven’t seen every episode, but perhaps my favorite among those I have seen is one in which a man manages to embed an unexploded grenade in his abdomen. This is one case where the ER doctors must make a house call. It appeals to me because the sometimes high-and-mighty Dr. Brackett gets a taste of the risks DeSoto and Gage and their peers face every day — sometimes several times a day. DeSoto and Gage become surgical nurses by necessity and earn Dr. Brackett’s praise and respect for their performance. I liked that. A lot.
Final words about Emergency!
It’s hard for me to say why I like Emergency! Part of it is the focus on medicine — I see health care as related to detective work. Sometimes the case is obvious. Sometimes you have to find more clues and put them together. I’m happy when I make the right diagnosis — Type 1 diabetes, tick bite, subdural hematoma — and when I learn about unfamiliar symptoms and conditions. When a Vietnam veteran uncharacteristically turns violent toward his wife, I don’t assume he suffers from PTSD — I wonder if he has a brain ailment (he does — a tumor).
While there are references to civilian life (DeSoto’s wife and children, Gage’s search for dates and the amateurish scheming he drags DeSoto into), there’s little emphasis on the personal. Early on, Dr. Brackett and Dixie are shown dating, but other than that we spend most of our time focused on the job — the mundane day-to-day life at the station of eating, gabbing, playing cards, and killing time punctuated at random intervals by emergency calls, and the ER at Rampart General (where they keep the coffee). We may not see our heroes at home, but we know enough about them to imagine what life is like outside the station and hospital.
Many episodes are not wrapped up neatly at the end. We see the paramedics work hard, but sometimes we don’t find out if the victims survive after they arrive at Rampart. There’s something satisfying about that — it’s more like life than TV.
Emergency! tackled issues that weren’t talked about much at the time, including middle-class child abuse and attempted suicide by a child, with the abuser portrayed by an attractive, chain-smoking Mariette Hartley. Dr. Brackett is not distracted, however, in his quest to confront mom, enlighten dad, and end the abuse.
Throughout their successes and occasional failures, our heroes remain passionate about saving lives in the field, where seconds count (see “ventricular fibrillation” above). Except for the occasional shenanigans (see “Gage” and “scheming” above), DeSoto and Gage remain regular, down-to-earth guys, frustrated more by their limitations than by the lack of accolades. They just do their job — and an interesting one it is to watch.
Andy M. Stewart: Man in the Moon
A Christmas Carol: 1938
Although A Christmas Carol with Alastair Sim is my favorite film version of the Charles Dickens story, I’ve found myself enjoying the 1938 movie with Reginald Owen several times. Filling in for the injured Lionel Barrymore, Owen delivers some lines a little too hurriedly, but captures the essence of the crusty capitalist before, during, and after his transformation.
As a side note, this film mentions that the poor take their dinners to the baker. This was of special interest to me because Elizabeth Gaskell notes the same tradition in Cranford. My edition of the novel explains that the poor used the leftover heat from the baker’s morning production to cook. I don’t know if this is in the original Dickens story, but it’s wonderful to see a small insight into daily life like that in a contemporary book and then in a film produced nearly 80 years later.
This version of the film focuses on the differences between childhood and adulthood, children and adults. When the juvenile Ebenezer is left behind at school for the holidays, he explains haughtily to a departing friend that he is to stay to continue his studies and that Christmas and its traditions are for children. Barely out of childhood, he justifies his father’s edict with the grim resignation of an adult. When his sister Fanny comes to retrieve him after his father’s reversal of mind, Ebenezer responds with a delight that mirrors Fanny’s own. This scene serves as a glimpse into Scrooge’s formative years, when he is neither child nor man.
Earlier, both Scrooge’s nephew, Fred, and his clerk, Bob Cratchit, had been portrayed as men-children. When he comes upon boys sliding down an icy hill, Fred cannot resist taking a few turns himself, attracting the notice of two of the Cratchit boys. Then, on his way home, Bob Cratchit turns a snowball attack on his formal adult person into a lesson on the fine art of making the perfect snowball. When one of the street urchins announces, “Here comes a topper!” Cratchit gleefully impresses his young friends with the accuracy of his aim — knocking the top hat off his curmudgeonly employer. Within an instant, Cratchit is transformed from impish boy into a careworn — and unemployed — father.
When the Ghost of Christmas Past tries to take Scrooge away from the reawakened memories of his childhood and youth, he demands to stay, like a difficult child. At a party in honor of Fred and his fiancee, Scrooge watches a game of blind man’s bluff with the wide eyes of a child (and seems not to notice the couple kissing in the foreground). When the Ghost of Christmas Present tells him it is time to leave, he pettishly refuses, stamping his feet and pounding his fists like the child within himself he is rediscovering.
In contrast, the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come takes Scrooge to the relentlessly dark world of adulthood. With the death of Tiny Tim, the ebullient spirit of Bob Cratchit and his family is diminished if not lost. Scrooge’s own death brings out only the sarcasm and greed of the “men of business” who are his peers; Scrooge leaves no children behind to mourn him.
By the end, Scrooge finds his inner child, the spirit of openness, generosity, and even fun that makes the poorest of street urchins and the lowliest of clerks happier than he. In his new-found joy, Scrooge gleefully engages an urchin to bring him a prize turkey for the Cratchit table.
Christmas is a time for family and friends and for the unspoiled spirit and wonder of childhood. In this movie, Scrooge becomes a good, even a great man by opening his elderly heart to the child he had never been allowed to be. I would not be surprised if he broke Fred and Peter’s record slides on the icy hill.
Spencer Tracy as Jekyll and Hyde
I’m sure they’ve been around for a while, but I’ve only recently discovered free on-demand movies. I’ve never bothered with a DVD player or a service like Netflix, so this is a good opportunity for me to see old movies with frequent breaks to accommodate my inborn restlessness.
Over the weekend, I watched Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, the 1941 version with Spencer Tracy, Lana Turner, and Ingrid Bergman. I wish I could remember the novel, but it has been decades since I read it. Even if the movie is not true to the book, it stands on its own as an interesting story.
I found the premise somewhat confusing; Dr. Jekyll seems to think that good and evil could be separated, although I’m not sure how the yelling man at the church service fit into this. He appears to be mentally ill (schizophrenia) rather than evil, and there are many worse crimes against humanity than disrupting a church service or interrupting the minister.
Like other fictional scientists of the 19th century, Dr. Jekyll experiments with the fundamental concepts of existence. Frankenstein creates life, while Dr. Jekyll tries to penetrate the secrets of the human soul.
According to Wikipedia, “Spencer Tracy’s performance in this film, out of all the performances he ever gave, was judged inadequate, and was one of his few critically roasted roles (Tracy was not considered frightening enough as Mr. Hyde, though he was quite good as Jekyll) . . . Tracy’s performance was routinely savaged when compared with March’s more monstrous version.”
My reaction was a little different. Tracy is not convincing as either a Victorian or as a scientist too ambitious to consider the ethical ramifications of his work. He doesn’t quite convey the single-minded devotion to his idea that is the hallmark of the mad, or nearly mad, scientist. The story line has him engaged to the Lana Turner character, although he is pointedly shown missing society dinners and functions with his fiancée and her father to indicate his commitment to his work. I’m not familiar with Tracy, but his Jekyll lacks an edge that seems vital to the character. He’s so bland that he doesn’t even seem to notice the very obvious advances of Ingrid Bergman’s barmaid/prostitute.
In this production, Hyde is more malicious prankster than personification of pure evil. While he is not handsome, he is not homely, either. The choice to use minimal makeup and effects makes Hyde even creepier than if he were shown to be a physical monstrosity, as he was in other versions. It is the combination of his words, his leering eyes, and his toothy smile that Ivy Peterson (Bergman) finds disturbing. Then, with much racy innuendo for 1941, she learns the painful way that he is not only a rapist, but a sadist who punishes her for the hatred he feels toward the man she loves — Dr. Jekyll.
The Victorians believed in physiognomy, the idea that outer appearance reflects inner temperament and character. This movie is better for eschewing this approach because a normal appearance encourages us to let down our guard. Unconsciously, we still expect a monster to act monstrously; we don’t expect a handsome, seemingly normal man like Ted Bundy to be a serial killer. Tracy’s Hyde dresses and looks like a gentleman, with a touch of something unsettling behind his eyes. While he is a prankster, slyly tripping a waiter and instigating a brawl, he is much darker, too, not only raping, beating, and murdering, but also gleefully gloating over the fear and loathing he inspires. His crimes are the culmination of the sadistic thrills that feed his existence. Ivy would rather die than live with the uncertainty of the depravities in which he may indulge. As I watched the movie, I did not experience a specific, all-out fear, but a more subtle, insidious, persistent anxiety, similar to Ivy’s.
Lana Turner is believable as the virtuous fiancée. She conveys the kind of sexuality that must have driven sexual tension in repressed Victorian society. When Dr. Jekyll says, “We love each other very much and want to be together,” his vision does not seem to be one of home, hearth, and family, the Victorian ideal, but of a sexy Lana Turner in his arms at last.
Unlike others, I was unimpressed by Bergman’s portrayal of the barmaid/prostitute, Ivy. In her first encounter with Dr. Jekyll, her rolling eyes and self-conscious smirks are hammy rather than naughty, flirty, or seductive. She can’t decide between her own accent and a lower-class English one. She also wavers between a tough-as-nails woman-of-the-street persona and a weak, naive one that finds Hyde’s depravities horrifying, perhaps even shocking. Her breakdown before Dr. Jekyll, as she asks for his protection, seems staged rather than spontaneous.
Despite the weaknesses in casting and performances, the flatness of the setting and atmosphere (which lack seediness and menace), and the glossing over of the ethical questions central to the story, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde still manages to disturb me and to remind me that horror doesn’t arise from what is seen and known, but from what is felt and anticipated. Hyde isn’t a monster because he’s ugly, physically deformed, and criminal; he’s a monster because our imagination gives him the power to frighten us with what he might do, and an ignited imagination is more powerful than any reality — or any film.